Payroll
Employee or contractor? How to tell the difference
Paying a worker as a contractor is simpler and cheaper than putting them on payroll. That's exactly why the IRS and the state look closely at it. What you call the person doesn't decide it. How the work is done does.
What the IRS looks at
- Who controls the work. If you set the hours, the method and the order of tasks, that points to an employee.
- Who carries the costs. Contractors use their own tools, pay their own expenses and can make or lose money on a job.
- The relationship. Ongoing, open-ended work that is central to your business points to an employee. A written contract helps, but it doesn't settle the question.
Quick signs
| More like an employee | More like a contractor |
|---|---|
| Works only for you | Has other customers |
| You set the schedule | Sets their own schedule |
| Uses your tools and truck | Brings their own |
| Paid by the hour or week | Paid by the job, sends an invoice |
| You train them in your way of doing it | Already has the skill and decides how |
Texas looks too
The Texas Workforce Commission makes its own decision for unemployment tax, and it can differ from what you assumed. A claim for unemployment benefits from a former "contractor" is often how the question comes up.
What it costs to get wrong
Back payroll taxes, penalties and interest, sometimes for several years and several workers at once.
If you're not sure
Treat a borderline worker as an employee, or ask the IRS to decide with Form SS-8. Whatever you choose, apply it the same way to everyone doing the same job.
Official sources
Rather hand this off?
Take the two-minute quiz. You’ll see a package and a price before you talk to anyone. Or just email us at yourteam@yourfinancegroup.com.
This guide is general information for Texas small businesses. It is not tax, legal or accounting advice for your situation. Perfect Fit Bookkeeping is a bookkeeping provider, not a CPA firm. Read our full disclaimers.